Homebuilder has registered a complaint versus Water District claiming water provided by the district causes leaks in domestic plumbing.

SANTA ANA: Two neighborhood developers have lodged grievances in Orange County Superior Court proclaiming standard water delivered by the Southern County water districts was corroding water pipe, which causes water leaks that require hundreds of thousands of dollars for copper repiping repair and installations.

Shapell Industries reported a claim November 2, alleging water sent out by Moulton Niguel Water District for Shapell homes across at least two Laguna Niguel residential districts; San Joaquin Hills in addition to Hillcrest were treated with chloramine, a chemical disinfectant that Shapell stated is known to cause pinhole leaks in the pipes of homeowners throughout the area.

The grievance states Shapell “will have to restore and upgrade plumbing in nearly 300 homes” in those local communities. The challenge may not specify what amount of homes which actually have water leaks. The construtor is going after around $7 million in losses, voicing defective products, negligence, private nuisance and breach of warranty.

MNWD provides service to 52,000 residences and businesses in Laguna Niguel, Aliso Viejo, Laguna Hills and portions of Mission Viejo and San Juan Capistrano.

“The only people filing a complaint pertaining to most of these leaks are living in properties made by Shapell in these few districts,” MNWD general manager Bob Gumerman said in his email. “If water was to blame, the issue would definitely be popular.”

Gumerman highlighted that the district’s water meets or is much greater than federal and state water-quality standards and it is suitable for drinking or other purposes. He explained Shapell hasn’t provided documents on how MNWD’s water supply has led to pin-hole pipe leaks in households. Numerous phone calls to the attorneys which represent Shapell weren’t returned.

Gumerman mentioned Moulton Niguel gets its water supply from the Metropolitan Water District of Southern California, who imports it out of the Colorado River and the State Water Project, a program of recollection areas, reservoirs and lakes. According to its internet site, MWD incorporates chloramine, a blend chlorine and ammonia, within the water treatment operation to remove organisms in drinking water.

MWD also delivers water for the Santa Margarita Water District, which services the rest of Mission Viejo in addition to Rancho Santa Margarita, Coto de Caza, Ladera Ranch along with the Talega community in San Clemente. MWD and SMWD were identified as as defendants with a challenge recorded Feb. 9 by Lennar Homes with regards to pinhole leaks in old pipes in the Verano community of Talega.

Lennar’s claim claims leaks in galvanized pipes in 70 Verano models “are the direct and/or alternative consequence of corrosive, extreme and/orincorrectly treated water” supplied by the districts. Lennar is looking for the districts to be held answerable for the pipe leaks as well as any costs, destruction or debt settlements suffered by Lennar as a result of the pipe leaks.

Newmeyer & Dillion attorney Carol Zaist, which will be representing Lennar, said the developer is unable to discuss pending lawsuits.

Newmeyer & Dillion also represents home builder Standard Pacific, which in the claim brought to the district in December found 75 properties in Ladera Ranch and Talega where home buyers have made note of pinhole leaking in water pipes and pertinent property damage. The assertion was initially turned down by SMWD officials, though newly released scientific studies may turned around this original determination.

SMWD speaker Michele Miller suggested the district need not change or modify the water available from MWD, in addition stating SMWD water satisfies or is higher than domestic water quality specifications. As to the results of drinking water treatment methods, “the district feels there isn’t any information to show that the particular region’s water is bringing about a corrosive relation to galvanized water pipes.”

Marc Edwards is known as a Virginia Tech civil and environmental engineering professor as well as nationally regarded specialist on water pipe corrosion. An element of his tasks are to study what causes pipe failures and approaches to deter them. He explained that a great many cases are emerging in California and that he is expecting to become held as an expert witness.

“We’ve done possibly more than a million dollars of experiments in the past six years,” Edwards said. “We’ve now observed that water chemistry and corrosive water are vital contributing factors of pinhole water leaks.

“We understand that additional circumstances are frequently connected, including increased velocity in water lines and mediocre installation practices, and therefore almost every lawsuit normally requires rather considerable forensic evaluation as a measure to examine the possible contributing factor and treatment plans,” he included.

Edwards said the equivalent guidelines carried out to make drinking water safer may perhaps be exacerbating pinhole pipe leaks. Even as disinfectants are required, far too much in a number of waters could very well be corrosive. He stated analysis on chloramine has confirmed it by itself doesn’t necessarily facilitate corrosion in pipes, but “it is quite possible, even probable, that chloramine plus elements within the water can be very highly corrosive.”

Though the District could have positive intentions, modifications to meet specifications may be suffering from unintentional implications, Edwards noted.

“You’ll find that there’s a good deal that we acknowledge,” he explained. “We have all completely proven that the water source is often a cause; not the only cause, but an underlying cause. There is however a bunch many of us still do not know.”

Live Help
Live Help